Places to Eat in Marco Island, FL

Are you looking for delicious restaurants to eat at in Marco Island? Follow along as we discuss some of the best restaurants in the city, like, Sunset Grille, Marco Prime Steakhouse, ARIO, and more.

When moving to a new area, it can be pretty intimidating. This guide is here to help you understand where the locals and visitors love to eat. Marco Island is a highly desired place to reside and visit. There are tons of different kinds of dining destinations located all within this Island. 

Marco Island is the largest of Florida's Ten Thousand Islands and is home so some of the most beautiful beaches and various things to do. People describe Marco Island as magical and alluring, constantly bringing in countless visitors and new residents. The Island is known for its white sandy beaches, expensive cost of living, casual lifestyle, fresh seafood, and exceptional real estate.

Even though this Island is one of the largest, it is only six miles by four miles in size. It is linked to the mainland by two bridges making it easily accessible. Marco Island currently has a permanent resident count of around 16,000, but during the peak winter season, they have a population of approximately 40,000. Overall, Marco Island is a great place to move to.

Keep reading along as we discuss some of the best dining destinations in Marco Island.

Here are the nine best restaurants in Marco Island, Florida.

Sale e Pepe

Price: $$$$

Specialty: Italian

Address: 480 S Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL

If you want a high-end Italian restaurant, check out Sale e Pepe. This restaurant is located at Beach Ocean Resort and offers made-from-scratch Southern Italian cuisine and delicious wine. It is an award-winning restaurant that overlooks the Gulf of Mexico and the white sand crescent beach of Marco Island. The atmosphere is relaxed but sophisticated. 

The menu is easy to navigate because it is refined and simple. Our favorite dish to begin the evening with is the Caprese, which is heirloom tomatoes, buffalo mozzarella, and pesto. It is delicious and has the perfect amount of food to share.

Moving on to the pasta selection, our go-to pasta dish is the Ravioli Carbonara. This dish has fresh pasta filled with ricotta, eggs, and guanciale. If you are not in the mood for pasta, don't fret. They have a variety of fish dishes, veal, lamb chop, filets, and more.

This is a great restaurant to visit if you are looking for a classy destination to enjoy a meal with your friends and family.

Snook Inn

Price: $$

Specialty: Seafood

Address: 1215 Bald Eagle Dr, Marco Island, FL

Snook Inn is your casual oceanfront seafood restaurant. It is known to be a chill hangout spot that serves delicious seafood and a salad bar. While you enjoy your meal, you can also enjoy the views at your waterfront table while listening to live music. It is the perfect place to experience authentic Island cuisine for lunch or dinner.

Snook Inn has various food options for you and your peers to enjoy. One of our go-to appetizers is the Ahi Tuna Nachos which comes with spiced tuna, seaweed salad, avocado, scallions, cucumber, wasabi cream, sriracha, and crispy wontons. Another one is the Smoked Wahoo Fish Dip, served with toasted crackers. Both of these options are great to share with your table.

They have a variety of soups and salads if you are looking for a meal on the lighter side. But our favorite dish here at Snoo Inn is the Fish N' Chips. 

This restaurant is currently closed for renovations, but when it opens back up, this place is a must-try.

Marco Prime Steak and Seafood

Price: $$$

Specialty: Steakhouse

Address: 599 S Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL

If you are looking for an upscale establishment to enjoy a meal, head over to Marco Prime Steak and Seafood Restaurant. This restaurant has soft lighting and rustic finishes offering steak and fish with a modern spin. It is a great place to visit if you are planning a date night or want to go out to eat to celebrate any occasion.

Keep reading to learn more about why Marco Prime has been voted one of the best restaurants on the Island. 

This establishment has a variety of meats and sides that are all made with the best quality ingredients. They have hot small plates, specialty dishes, a la carte meats, ceviche, carpaccio, soups, salads, and a handful of sides and sauces to choose from. Our favorite dish at Marco Prime is the Surf and Turf. This dish has filet mignon, lobster tail, housemade mashed potatoes, and asparagus. 

The Oyster Society

Price: $$$

Specialty: Seafood

Address: 599 S Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL

At The Oyster Society, you will be served high-end seafood. They also have a raw bar, fine wines, and craft cocktails. This establishment is located in the heart of Marco Island and is known as one of the best restaurants in Marco Island. 

The menu at The Oyster Society is handcrafted to offer delicious pairings for all of the entrees. They have the largest selection of oysters in South Florida and Marco Island, with new choices regularly. Everything served at this restaurant is fresh.

The menu is straightforward to navigate. They have a raw bar, snacks to share, soups, salads, sushi, chef's specialties, fresh meats, sauces, and sides. Our favorite appetizer to get for our friends and family to share is the Pork Belly Bao Buns. This comes with pork belly, cucumber, red onion, Korean aioli, and kimchi salads. 

Moving on to the chef's specialties, our go-to dish is the Lobster and Crab Encrusted Sea Bass. This is served with garlic broccolini, lobster butter sauce, and mashed potatoes. It is the perfect dish to try a little bit of everything.

La Tavola Restaurant and Bar

Price: $$

Specialty: American

Address: 961 Winterberry Dr, Marco Island, FL

La Tavola Restaurant and Bar is a warm, sparse eatery that offers classic American cuisine and seafood. This restaurant earned its name because 'La Tavola' means the table. The table is the place where family and friends gather to share laughter, love, and life. Here, you will be served only fresh, seasonal ingredients to ensure your meal is exceptional. 

La Tavola serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner. They also have a happy hour menu.

For breakfast, a favorite local dish is the Salmon Benedict. This comes with two poached eggs, smoked salmon, corned beef, cucumbers, hollandaise sauce, a fresh baguette, and house-seasoned potato wedges.

For lunch, our go-to meal is the Lobster Roll. This roll comes with lobster, celery, and sour cream on a toasted brioche bun with a side of seasoned potato wedges.

We love to begin the evening with a Grilled Caesar Salad for dinner. You will be served grilled romaine lettuce, shaved pecorino, parmesan crisps, garlic toast, baby heirloom tomatoes, and a housemade creamy Caesar dressing. For our meal, we love the Chicken Milanese that is served with breaded organic chicken breast, white truffle creamy polenta, tomato, onion, arugula salad and shaved Reggiano. 

This place is the perfect spot to bring your friends and family and enjoy any meal of the day.

ARIO

Price: $$

Specialty: American

Address: 400 S Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL

If you want a place to enjoy steaks, chops, and other familiar American food in a contemporary setting, head over to the ARIO in Marco Island. It is a fine-dining steakhouse that offers an elegant menu that is all locally sourced. You can choose from steaks or fresh seafood with a delicious wine or handcrafted cocktails.

ARIO is a signature steakhouse that has a menu that is globally inspired. You can choose from their in-house 35-day, dry-aged steaks or fresh seafood. ARIO takes pride in believing fine dining should be orchestrated like an art form, enabling experiences that are thought-provoking and delicious.

Our favorite salad at this restaurant is the Crab Salad. This is served with cured egg yolk, grana padano, creme fraiche dressing, pickled mustard seeds, and gem lettuce. We also love the Lobster Bisque.

Then, of course, we continue the evening by ordering one of the signature 35-day dry-aged steaks with a side of carrots and asparagus. 

This place is a perfect dining destination for you and your peers to visit and enjoy an amazing meal.

Mango's Dockside Bistro

Price: $$

Specialty: American

Address: 760 N Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL

This bistro is your casual, laid-back dining destination that serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Mango's Dockside Bistro offers the best family-friendly waterfront dining. It is located in the heart of Marco Island, The Esplanade on Smokehouse Bay. This restaurant boasts fantastic views of the water and amazing food to match. 

Visit Mango's and enjoy their staters, homemade soups, burgers, seafood, steak, salads, pasta, sandwiches, seafood platters, and desserts. Our go-to appetizer at this restaurant is the Hush Puppies. These hush puppies are made with jalapeno and grilled corn in fried cornmeal dumplings, served with mango butter. These hush puppies melt in your mouth.

Our favorite burger at Mango's is the Whiskey Burger. This burger is topped with pepper jack cheese, onion rings, and a side of smokey whiskey demi-glace sauce. Most of the time, we add bacon and mushrooms for even more flavor.

The Deck at 560

Price: $$$

Specialty: American

Address: 560 S Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL

This upscale eatery is at the Hilton Beach Resort and Spa, specializing in steaks and seafood dishes. When enjoying your meal at The Deck at 560, you will get to experience breathtaking Gulf-front views featuring white sand beaches and unforgettable watercolor sunsets.

This restaurant offers a breakfast buffet from 7 am until noon, and they offer a regular menu from 7 am until 11 am. You can enjoy the lunch menu from noon until 4 pm daily, and then dinner is from 5 pm until 10 pm. 

Our favorite breakfast meal is the Avocado Toast which comes with avocado, lime, sea salt, and crushed red pepper on multigrain bread. 

For lunch, we love to enjoy the Mediterranean flatbread. This comes with spinach, sundried tomato, fire-roasted pepper, kalamata olives, caramelized onions, mozzarella, feta, and a balsamic reduction. 

For dinner, we love to start off with Lamb Meatballs. These meatballs come with rice grits, mint chimichurri, and toasted pine nuts. Then we love to enjoy the Pan Roasted Chicken, which is served with sweet potato puree, brown butter, leeks, and asparagus. 

Sunset Grille

Price: $$

Specialty: Sports Bar

Address: 900 S Collier Blvd, Marco Island, FL

If you are looking for a relaxed oceanfront sports bar, check out Sunset Grille. This restaurant has dozens of TVs and sunset views. You can enjoy these things while eating a delicious burger, wings, and other pub food. 

This menu has an extensive selection of a little bit of everything. It's a great restaurant to visit with your friends and family to enjoy a casual meal. They have delicious appetizers like Loaded Nachos, Steak Tacos, Buffalo Wings, Cheese Curds, and more to choose from.

Sunset Grille has a handful of burgers to choose from and also wings. If you are looking for something on the lighter side, they have a variety of salads and soups to choose from. If you are looking for something heavier, check out their section on sandwiches. Our favorite is the Shrimp Po-Boy.

Best Restaurants in Marco Island, FL - Our Last Words

We hope you found this guide helpful when trying to decide what restaurant to eat at with your friends or family. As you can tell, a lot of these restaurants serve steak and seafood. When living in or visiting Marco Island, the best things to order at restaurants are fresh seafood.

If you are considering moving to Marco Island, Florida, you can contact us here to get connected with a local Real Estate professional for further guidance in the buying and selling process in Florida.